Follow us on 
BS Motoring Web  
  Wednesday, May 22, 2013
 
HomeCarsBikesTravelGalleryBlogsMagazineWeb TVAbout us
  Tests    Reviews    News    Features    Motorsports    Motor shows    Classics    Quick Comparisons
 
Home Cars Quick Comparos
Volkswagen Vento vs Hyundai Verna
Which one is the best Rs 8-10 lakh diesel sedan?
By : BSM | Published : October 05, 2010 | Photos : BSM
Email   Print   [] Comment      
Volkswagen Vento
More Photos | Video
Is there's anyone who is best known for a diesel sedan under Rs 10 lakh, with a right combination of performance and practicality, then it's Hyundai and their Verna that come to the top of most people's minds. And while the Verna has gone through a "Transform"ation recently, it now has to contend with a pretty strong competitor - the Volkswagen Vento.

For many, the Vento is nothing more than a Polo with a boot, but VW have worked their way in to ensure it gets a longer wheelbase and more interior room. In fact, room here is a tad better than the Verna, both for the front and rear seat occupants. On the outside, the Verna Transform is not something of sheer beauty and is a bit too radical for most people's tastes. The Vento, on the other hand has a nice balanced look, even though we'd have liked to see a more interesting tail lamp design.

Going back to the inside, it's the Vento who has a more interesting interior, while the Verna can be termed 'par for the course'. The overall feel of the materials of the Vento give you the impression of being of a much higher grade, while the Verna does have a lot of colours to provide relief. Beige is highly used for both, though it's a tad more in the Vento than the Verna.

The engines on both the cars are quite torquey. While the 1.5-litre diesel on the Verna has more power and is more refined, the one on the Vento is a tad bit torquier. Both will get to 100 kph in under 12 seconds, but it's the Vento that is a shade quicker. The 110 horsepower Verna simply loses out to the higher displacement, 104 bhp Vento on account of torque as well as gearing. The Vento has slightly shorter gearing which helps it get there quicker. Efficiency-wise, it is the Vento that scores marginally over the Verna in the combined cycle. But the Verna fights back by offering an automatic gearbox option, which the Vento currently doesn't offer.

Dynamically too, it is the Vento that feels more sure-footed and more predictable. It turns into corners better and rides quite well too. The Verna feels more comfortable on arrow-shot straight roads and a bit too nervous and understeery around corners. There's also more pitch and body roll in the car due to its soft suspension while ride quality is a bit more pliant here.

Even though the Verna's price tag of Rs 7.84 to 9.19 lakh (ex-showroom, Mumbai) cannot hide the fact that the Vento (Rs 8.19-9.46 lakh) is a more superior car in terms of engine performance, dynamics, interiors and overall competence. The Verna also feels a half generation older when compared to its German competition and doesn't do anything spectacularly. In the end, the Vento overwhelmingly leaves the Verna behind.

return story content
Pages :| 1 
Advertisements
Blend of dynamic handling and refined engineering
It’s like the wind beneath your wings that drives you closer Click here
Maximum Options of choicest properties. Buy Sell Rent.
Take your family on fun filled vacation. know more.
Invest in Gold Mutual Funds and ETF’s online for FREE
Plans for every business size and need. Explore your options
You play multiple roles in the game of life. know more
Email Print [12] Comment        
blog comments powered by Disqus
  Posted by aniket at 19th February,2012
which is the best car to buy within 10-11 lacs INR. in terms of brand value, comforts, technology, handling, maintainence, etc.
  Posted by Anubha Prasad at 13th December,2011
I want to buy a diesel car within Rs.10 lakh budget. My prorities are fuel economy, low cost of ownership & style $ of course performance.. I have narrowed down on Vento diesel trendline, Skoda Rapid Ambition, Nissan Sunny diesel & Fluidic Verna 1.6. Please guide me. The vehicle would be mostly chauffer driven & will run for about 50 km per day. Shall be grateful for yr advice.
  Posted by Mahesh at 8th August,2011
I want to purchase a new car so kindly, Please tell which car in terms of performance, latest technology, value for money car, low maintenance, among the following cars. My budget is around ten lakes. 1. Maruti sx4 diesel vxi/zxi 2. Maruti swift desire diesel 3. Hyundai new verna diesel 4. volkswagon vento diesel highline please tell me in detail the difference between these cars in terms of technology, long term usage, safety wise, price, etc. Mahesh
  Posted by RPG at 2nd June,2011
HAVE YOU SEEN NEW FLUIDIC VERNA?
  Posted by DRG at 22nd March,2011
Vento may be a better car with many good technical abilities, But the dealer attitude kills. No customization for India for example, \"door locks open from inside on front doors even after locking\". I as a user cannot simply fool yself by saying this is technically very good and live day to day short comings and nuissances like dealer attitude.
  Posted by christy abraham at 8th March,2011
Vento is just a flat match-stick box on wheels compared to Verna. Also though u say VW\'s attempt to make a sedan out of a hatchback, i would say ur say is totally biased..ABSOLUTELY BIASED..its never necessary for a new model to be always better than an existing model.
  Posted by meghaj at 19th January,2011
i own hyundai verna transform SX VGT CRDI hijack attempt of my hyundai verna transform but saved because of immobilizer. wake up at 2 mid night by siren and saw my hyundai verna transform being pushed by thieves.they were not able to start but damaged ignition key lock and door lock.immobilizer worked and car was saved. saved by hyundai security but road side assistance is pathetic. my vehicle is still in service centre since 10th of january as they calling key lock set and immobilizer a dead stock.anyway part arrived after 7 days and installed yesterday.On enquiry i came to know that one more part is required and it will take 3-4 days more.Why that part was not being ordered with key lock set and other stuff on 10th of 11 of jan. this what people of hyundai do at service centre So at last-my vehicle still in service centre,more to wait which shows not only road side assistance is patehetic but also after sales service and parts availability. think of parts availability, road sid
  Posted by goutham at 27th December,2010
I never would have compared a rock solid german engineered car with a soft pitched korean one... I accept japanece vs greman seems interesting to hear....
  Posted by Premchand at 24th December,2010
I had recently evaluated both the cars. Vento definitely scores better in terms of design and space. It does give the Polo sibling look, but it's totally different from the inside in terms of ergonomics and design. Wonderfully crafted vehicle. Diesel mill churns out a decent power, but not as responsive and muscular as that of the Verna. Verna packs a peppy engine that's quite happy and comfortable at the lower rpms as well as at the 3000+ mark. At just over 10L, Vento should be a better choice for an all round performance package. With VW eyeing the premium sedan market, it does leave behind questions on their service quality/consistency and ofcourse cost of service.
  Posted by Srini vellore at 30th October,2010
Regarding service Verna Gets Mark . also Germans Charge more in billing, As Skoda is an Example ,No service but bill kills us. Compare mileage and Maintenance costs of both , then we agree which one is best in this category I think Verna gets competition now in diesel segment.
  Posted by D MAITRA at 22nd October,2010
FANTASTIC ANALYSIS. I HAVE SEEN VENTO RECENTLY IN THE SHOW ROOM. IT IS MORE ROOMY,ELEGANT THAN VERNA. GERMAN ENGINEERING IS ALWAYS BEST MAY BE LESS AERODYNAMIC BUT VERY STARIGHTFORWARD,SIMPLE ELEGANT LOOK. PETROL MILEAGE CLAIMED BY COMPANY 12KM/L IN CITY & HIGH WAY 17KM/L WHICH IS REALLY GOOD CONSIDERING THE STRONG BODY & 1600C.C. ENGINE OF VENTO. AFTER ALL EUROPEAN & AMERICAN CARS ARE MORE STYLISH THAN ASIAN COUNTERPARTS. I AM HAVING FORD ICON FLAIR SINCE 2005 WHICH I FEEL IS MUCH STRONGER & HAVING STYISH LOOK THAN MANY ASIAN CARS ESPECIALLY IN THE MID SIZE SEDAN SEGMENT. I WOULD PREFER VENTO AS MY NEXT CAR OVER ANY ASIAN CAR.
  Posted by Hi at 19th October,2010
Hi
Read Emailed Commented
Other Manufacturers Other Models
 
Explore BSMOTORING.COM
  Home   Cars   Bikes   Gallery   General   Resources   Explore Group Network
 Quick Comparisons
 Road Tests
 Motofocus
 Motorsports
 Destinations
 Tests
 Reviews
 News
 Features
 Motorsports
 Motor shows
 Classics
 Quick Comparisons
 Tests
 Reviews
 News
 Features
 Motorsports
 Motor shows
 Classics
 Quick Comparisons
 Photo Gallery
 Video Gallery
 Wallpaper
 Travel
 Blogs
 Magazine
 About us
 Archives
 Register
 Feedback
 Archives
 Advertise with us
 Contact Us
 Business-standard.com
 bshindi.com
 Archives
 Livemarkets
 smartportfolio II