Verna vs SX4 vs City vs Vento - End of the road?
     Follow us on 
BS Motoring Web  
  Wednesday, May 23, 2012
 
HomeCarsBikesTravelGalleryBlogsMagazineWeb TVAbout us
  Tests    Reviews    News    Features    Motorsports    Motor shows    Classics    Quick Comparisons
 
Home Cars Road Test
Verna vs SX4 vs City vs Vento - End of the road?
Can the Hyundai Verna usurp the position of the best C-segmenter? We find out
By : Rohin Nagrani | Published : August 03, 2011
Email Print [21] Comment   Facebook Facebook   Add to Favorites Twitter  
More Photos | Video
Few roads can tell you what a car is truly capable of. An open, winding road is one of them. More often than not, it tells you what a car feels like, and whether it has all the trappings of a winner. But sometimes, they kill misconceptions, and bring out newer beliefs. It’s hard to explain, even harder to justify them, but such is life.

The new Hyundai Verna somehow started on just such a page. The previous car didn’t do anything wrong, but it didn’t do much right either. It led a life of mediocrity and therefore was blessed with mediocre performance even on the sales charts. Numerous facelifts, one as recent as last year, didn’t do much to change its fortunes. A sliver of hope, then, lies on the shoulders of the new one, a car that Hyundai hopes will change its luck in the C-segment and above as it plans an onslaught of new cars this year and the next.

The going won’t be easy. In a segment that has a VFM car like Maruti Suzuki’s SX4, a car with engineering finesse in the form of the Volkswagen Vento and the all-conquering Honda City whose only mistake is the lack of a diesel option, the Verna can feel truly overwhelmed. But can it overcome? We hit the open road, a road that truly opened our eyes to a new set of winners. And some really close results.

MORE ON PAGE 2>>

Pages :| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 
More Photos:
    
Advertisements
Journey on, We are by Your Side. Click here to know more
Benefits Upto Rs. 2.36 Lakhs on the Fully Loaded TJet Petrol.
The Best Seller is Also the No. 1 in Mileage. Click here
Invest in Real Estate. Villas in Bangalore starting @ Rs.66 lacs
One of the leading business schools in the world.Know More
Email Print [21] Comment   Facebook Facebook   Add to Favorites Twitter    
blog comments powered by Disqus
  Posted by VIJAI at 13th February,2012
Kindly suggest the diesel version best out of the following , if variants can be specified will be more useful . 1. skoda rapid 2. Vento 3. Verna fluidic 4. Maruti sx 4
  Posted by IRFAN BANDUKWALA at 23rd November,2011
Very informative but does not answer if we should take the Honda City or the Verna fluidic Diesel
  Posted by R Rangarajan at 9th November,2011
Also forgot the Chevy Optra?And where is Linea?Honda City is the best car in the range,but,Linea is better in terms of features and ride.Optra is a size larger than the Verna,Linea,City,SX4 and Vento but is priced near these cars.And i hope that Skoda Rapid,which will be launched in 7 days time,will outdoe these cars.
  Posted by Saikumar at 11th September,2011
Pretty good attempt to picture out the comparisons.Thanks. Wish the Linea T-jet and Multijet were a part of this comparison to make it whole some. Today , we have the New Ford Fiesta to add up the line length more.Arrival of Lauretta will add some more spice to sedans in India.Nevertheless , good times for buyers and busy schedule for you guys.Keep going.
  Posted by Aravind Raman at 26th August,2011
Guys, many readers have felt bad about Fiat Linea's exclusion. But what is the root cause of it not selling? I heard After Sales Service is the issue. Is it the sole reason for abysmal sales? Why is a supposedly good product not selling?
  Posted by Aravind Raman at 26th August,2011
Very good comparison; but actually bit incomplete and already obsolete as car prices have bee revised. Honda City will win any day in petrol sedan comparison and I do speak from an ownership perspective. With the recent price cut by Honda, no need to compare any further! If petrol, buy Honda. Period. I felt high end versions Fiat Linea and Ford Fiesta could have been included for diesel comparison. But my guess is Hyundai Verna Fluidic diesel would any day win hands down with a good margin. May be, that is the reason they were not included in the comparison by the experts!
  Posted by kin at 21st August,2011
And wht abt chevy optra magnum?spacious powerful and refined engine.Good handling and travel comfort.Value for money.
  Posted by Lavkesh Arora at 9th August,2011
Another Hyundai with lots of unnecessary curves, lines and what not and a diesel engine which is too much for the suspension and chassis to handle. Mind you such an engine will work fine in a Linea or a Fiesta but the Korean doesn't know how to design a good handling, stiff chassis. Mediocrity moves on and like the absolutely average i20 this will also sell. We ought to know our cars better. P.S. Thumbs down for excluding Linea from this. The best riding and handling car in the group.
  Posted by Kunal at 9th August,2011
Very nice article, though don't agree with couple of things. Overall Verna wins in the Diesel's sedan. Vento could be close or anything, but lacks big time on looks, features, after sale & services. VW will take a lot of time in improving these loopholes. In cheap sedan, Sx4 wins the game, in overall sedan, verna wins the race. About handling part, don't agree with couple of things as it depends on person to person, their experience etc. City is a better looking car but lack of features and a Diesel engine is big NO in todays world. Overall, Verna is the winner in Diesel sedans and in cheap sedans, Sx4 wins. Vento has to improve looks, features & services to win over Hyundai & Maruti. Cheers!
  Posted by Manish at 9th August,2011
Doesn't Fiat Linea in both the versions specially T-jet qualify for this comparison? I believe it will beat all the competitors hands down for the price and specifications and quality it offers.After sales service is a very subjective issue and city specific. Kindly include Fiat Linea and lets see there after
  Posted by Velutha at 8th August,2011
Too little (no Linea, no Fiesta) too late (you could have justified this INCOMPLETE shootout by doing it before the Fiesta's launch)
  Posted by motorock at 8th August,2011
People want goodies, equipment and comfort from these cars which will spend more than 95% of their time in traffic-that's where Verna really wins. It is funny when reviewers speak of "performance" from these family oriented cars! Linea's omission is glaring too. Dislike
  Posted by ADMIN at 8th August,2011
Readers, despite our attempts to get a Linea into the story, the car wasn't available in time (neither T-Jet nor diesel). Secondly, this story appeared in the July issue of Motoring and the cars were shot and tested before the Fiesta was launched.
  Posted by motorock at 7th August,2011
An uneducated inference, esp in the Petrol. The exclusion of Linea,BSM's bias towards Hondas and not understanding the segment are glaring downs of the compare. People want goodies, equipment and comfort from these cars which will spend more than 95% of their time in traffic. It is funny when reviewers speak of "performance" from these family oriented cars! Dislike
  Posted by R Rangarajan at 7th August,2011
Verna has the best engine ,but I still prefer the Honda City's rev-happy i-VTEC engine.So it is the best one of the lot.
  Posted by motorock at 6th August,2011
I agree, the Linea should have been here which is better than SX4 any day. I have seen a Honda bias in BSM which is sad- and when reviewers compare "power & performance" in these segments, it is funny. These segments are family-oriented and none can really be thrown around corners-this segment is all about goodies and comfort. For "performance", please get the right kit. Very immature compare. Dislike
  Posted by Doc at 5th August,2011
I'll add my voice to these three guys...shame that the Linea was not taken into consideration...I don't like saying it, but are any of you auto journos really unbiased? Is your conscience clear? The whole lot of you are hopelessly pro-Honda and pro-VW...the shocking lack of features in the Vento and City should have had you seething with fury - instead, you just gloss over these issues!
  Posted by Sudhish at 5th August,2011
Bring the Fiat in, boys!
  Posted by Amriyt at 4th August,2011
You should have definitely considered the Fiat Linea for this shoot. I know it doesnt sell, but its a fantastic car. Boo!!
  Posted by Pravin at 4th August,2011
What about Fiat Linea T-Jet and Fiat Linea Diesel.. How can you discount Linea and compare the rest? I think Linea is a better Petrol than City and Linea Diesel is a strong contender though the Verna Diesel is the best!!
  Posted by Tejus at 4th August,2011
Is it too early to include the New Fiesta in such comparos? Also, as Pravin says, why not the Linea? The T-Jet is supposed to be brilliant to drive and is loaded to the gills.
Twitter
Follow BSMotoring on Twitter
Read Emailed Commented
Other Manufacturers Other Models
 
Explore BSMOTORING.COM
  Home   Cars   Bikes   Gallery   General   Resources   Explore Group Network
 Quick Comparisons
 Road Tests
 Motofocus
 Motorsports
 Destinations
 Tests
 Reviews
 News
 Features
 Motorsports
 Motor shows
 Classics
 Quick Comparisons
 Tests
 Reviews
 News
 Features
 Motorsports
 Motor shows
 Classics
 Quick Comparisons
 Photo Gallery
 Video Gallery
 Wallpaper
 Travel
 Blogs
 Magazine
 About us
 Archives
 Register
 Feedback
 Archives
 Subscribe to Magazine
 Advertise with us
 Contact Us
 Business-standard.com
 bshindi.com
 Archives
 Livemarkets
 smartportfolio II