Follow us on 
BS Motoring Web  
  Tuesday, Sep 16, 2014
 
HomeCarsBikesTravelGalleryBlogsWeb TVAbout us
  Tests    Reviews    News    Features    Motorsports    Motor shows    Classics    Quick Comparisons
 
Home Cars Road Test
Skoda Fabia 1 4 TDi vs Ford Fusion 1 4 TDCi - Brands Hatch
Two Big Diesel-Powered Hatchbacks.One Big Winner.Simple,Right?
By : Srinivas Krishnan | Published : April 18, 2008 | Photos : Aman Chaudhary
Email   Print   [] Comment      
More Photos | Video
Are you a no-nonsense person or do you want to feel special? Ford says that its Fusion appeals to both the left brain as well as the right, while Skoda says that the Fabia is the only hatchback that pampers you this well. While Ford again says that the Fusion is a great match of practicality and frugality, Skoda says that since you are a special person, you need a car that comes with a host of accessories as standard. And you know what I say to all that? Here goes...

I really liked the last generation Fabia hatch, and was generally known as the Fabia-man in Skoda’s previous management circles. And much to my chagrin, Skoda took its own time to introduce the Fabia in our country. But the Fabia they wanted to launch a few years back was the sedan version, rather than the hatch, which they felt would be too expensive for India. It’s another thing that the second-generation Fabia that we have here is not cheap by any standard. What tilted the scales towards Skoda introducing the hatch was that famous excise duty cut for small cars (below 4,000 mm in length and with engine capacities less than 1500cc for diesel and 1200cc for petrol). Even Ford benefited with this piece of legislation when they gave the Fusion a facelift in 2006 and introduced the diesel version last year. And like with the Fabia, it’s not exactly cheap – Ford is still struggling to convince people that it’s not your average hatchback and is a unique car. But that does not stop us from comparing these two, right?

Design
Quickly tell me, which is the newer car here? Yeah, yeah, I know that was a stupid question, as even a blind man can make that out. Since the time the Fusion was first launched in Europe, car manufacturers have been able to beautifully craft sheetmetal in new ways economically, which is why we are seeing some sharp sections, crisp lines and funky curves even in non-luxury cars. The Fabia is a fine example of this. Actually, if you remember how simple the last-gen Fabia looked, you’ll understand how sophisticated things have got with its replacement. Though I still have strong feelings for the old Fabia, I have to come to terms with this new sophistication. People may like that gratuitous use of chrome on the grille (it reminds me too much of that gawky Roomster concept), while those projector headlamps in the Elegance version make it look cross-eyed (I swear!). Yet, the Euro-chic lines of what is essentially a conventional hatchback format makes the Fabia refreshing on our roads.

Fabia :  ***
Fusion :  **

Interior and Comfort
For all its external sophistication, the Fabia is remarkably simple inside. The layout is traditional and quite uncluttered. The controls for the climatiser are placed well above where you’d normally see them and you have the luxury of two gloveboxes, but beyond that, there is nothing radical about the Fabia dash. Quality of course is quite good of all the plastics and the switchgear and they look as if they will last beyond five successive owners of the car. The instrument console is typical Skoda, with two big dials for the tacho and speedo. The Elegance version comes with an electric sunroof plus parking sensors and its respective LCD display... it seems like a bit of an indulgence in a hatchback. 

The Fusion dash is of course a host of cubbyholes that have been put together. Its utilitarian nature on the outside is thus reflected inside as well. The parts-bin sharing from the Fiesta means familiar needles, gauges and controls. I like the soft rubbery texture of the dash, but the quality of plastics and the way the doors shut is not as good as that of the Fabia’s. What goes in the Fusion’s favour is that it has a longer wheelbase and thus more legroom for rear passengers... oh, and much more luggage space in the rear as well. Both cars have good enough seats all around though, with adequate thigh support. So it is like this; while the Ford interiors are practical, thoughtful and spacious, the Fabia makes you feel good and warm and that all is well with the world outside. The battle evens out here.
Fabia :  ***
Fusion :  ***

Powertrain and Performance
The Fusion’s diesel motor is the same one that powers the Fiesta. Displacing 1399cc, the four-cylinder turbocharged motor develops 68 horses at 4000 rpm and 16.31 kgm of turning force at 2000 revs. The motor is a remarkably fuel efficient one and is adequate for the kind of driving one would expect to do with this car. It is quite refined for a small oilburner, and NVH levels are well under control. The gearing is also well-suited to the nature of the engine and does a good job in terms of driveability. But before we go on, meet the Fabia’s turbodiesel motor. It’s one pot less than the Fusion’s engine but also puts out identical horsepower at the same rpm, while torque is at 15.81 kgm between 1600 and
2800 revs. It is a bit noisy, because of the inherent nature of a three-cylinder diesel, I suppose. The last time we saw a three-cylinder diesel motor was in the Hyundai Accent, and that was a blast when it came to performance. Compared to that, the Fabia’s diesel motor is tame. The reason could be that since the cost of acquiring the car is so high, one might as well keep the running costs low! The five-speed gearbox of the Fabia shifts positively and engages well, as compared to the Fusion’s gear lever action, which is just a wee bit rubbery (the rubber ‘bellows’ covering the lever don’t help either!), but it’s nothing to crib too much about.
Pages :| 1 | 2 | 3 
Advertisements
Email Print [0] Comment        
blog comments powered by Disqus
Read Emailed Commented
Other Manufacturers Other Models
 
Explore BSMOTORING.COM
  Home   Cars   Bikes   Gallery   General   Resources   Explore Group Network
 Quick Comparisons
 Road Tests
 Motofocus
 Motorsports
 Destinations
 Tests
 Reviews
 News
 Features
 Motorsports
 Motor shows
 Classics
 Quick Comparisons
 Tests
 Reviews
 News
 Features
 Motorsports
 Motor shows
 Classics
 Quick Comparisons
 Photo Gallery
 Video Gallery
 Wallpaper
 Travel
 Blogs
 About us
 Archives
 Register
 Feedback
 Archives
 Advertise with us
 Contact Us
 Business-standard.com
 bshindi.com
 Archives
 Livemarkets
 smartportfolio II