Mahindra Log-on
Login Login Go Forgot
password
register
bsm web Search
HomeCarsBikesTravelGalleryBlogsMagazineWeb TVAbout us
  Quick Comparisons  |  Road Tests  |  Motofocus  |  Motorsports  |  Destinations
BSM Home
  You are here: Home > Storypage
  

Mahindra Log-on

By:Rohin Nagrani |Published :April 19, 2010
Bookmark and Share       [6] Comments  | Add  
More Photos | Video

After weeks of speculation, there is finally an end to the whole Mahindra-Renault saga. Renault will exit the JV, Mahindra will continue to manufacture and sell the Logan for a royalty fee and the French company will concentrate its efforts towards setting up its manufacturing in Chennai with Nissan and a sales and after-sales network. There is an air of amicability around the whole episode and more than anything, dealers can now heave a sigh of relief and push the Logan with renewed energy. While Anand Mahindra continues to maintain that despite the takeover, the company's focus is still UVs, I somehow don't think it's quite possible.

If you will notice, 2010 is a defining year in the Indian auto industry, more so than some of the previous years. With consolidation and new products from existing manufacturers, there will be a whole bunch of them who will finish FY 2010-11 with sales figures in the six-digit arena. Some of them like GM and Ford will be doing so for the first time in 15 years while others like VW and Nissan with their minimal presence could be looking at a 10 to 50 jump fold from their existing situation. Then, Toyota and Honda are expected to join the bandwagon and in this melee it is quite likely that M&M's will not want to be left out in the passenger car/vehicle space.

India is at the cusp of now heading on the same growth path as China's auto industry, of course if financial, macro-economic and other factors don't play spoilsport. And everyone would want a pie of it. To stick to the stance that UVs will continue to be their core is somewhat sensible but somewhat foolhardy too. What I'd really like to see is M&M complete their transportation circle. They moved into two wheelers, commercial vehicles and even aircraft and boats in the recent years! The latter two have tremendous growth potential, two-wheeler business requires marketing acumen and commercial vehicles is as tempestous an industry as has ever been. So to say M&M wants to mitigate its risk and therefore not take major steps into the passenger car arena may just end up becoming a boat they might not want to miss.

They have the right product to begin with in the form of the Logan, have acquired the expertise and engineering skills from former partner Ford and now Renault and with some external help thrown in can really start manufacturing India-centric cars. It's good to know that the platform could spawn a compact Logan and an SUV, but M&M would be better off by looking at more avenues. I'd really like to see M&M bring a proper hatch with nice styling cues in the next two years or so, something in the Rs 3.8-5 lakh bracket. I'd also like to see a second generation Logan along with it and maybe even feature a sportier version with about 100-115 bhp, stiffened suspension, a quicker turning steering and some nice body-kit to complement it. I'd also like to see Mahindra finally shed its image of being just a UV maker and don the suit of one that can also make world class cars. Because if Mahindra can spread themselves across sectors and do a good job of it, am sure it won't be all that difficult to make and sell a serious number of cars every year now, can't it?

Bookmark and Share      Top Pages :| 1 
Tags: Mahindra Renault |  Logan |  JV |  Rohin Nagrani |  blog    
Advertisements
Only Developer to give a guarantee on time space & rate.
Now property search gets more exciting than ever before!
Making lives better through Social Innovation Business..
India's No. 1 Property Site. Click here to know more.
Health is Wealth..... Insurance + Savings... Know More...
Comment on this Article
Name:
Email:
 [6] Comments
Ruman Devmane
25th April,2010
Reply
Competing with International vehicles is fair - but the bigger question is, Why? Would you ring M.Schumacher's residence asking if you could borrow his Ferrari if you "felt like driving a bit fast in your basement parking"? The Xylo serves its purpose, that of ferrying 6 to 8 people in comfort, at decent speeds, and being reliable - and as Rohin pointed out in one of his earlier blogs, it rides better than the Audi Q7 on our (infamous) roads. Secondly, markets abroad, leaving aside South American and backward African zones, see no need for vehicles like Sumos, Boleros or even Xylos for that matter. Our country cannot do without these vehicles. They're efficient (Bolero DI, Xylo and the Eeco, for that matter), can fit in a family and the dog, and is more economical to run than a Honda CR-V in all aspects. And hence, 'vintage jeeps' (with dual a/cs, power steering, power everything) cater to us best. Drive an "International class" CR-V through a crater - and that happens a lot
ASX
21st April,2010
Reply
The problem it seems is that the two major Indian manufactures are working in their golden silos. Their products do not compete with any real international product. The diesel Indica and now the Nano have no competition whatsoever. While Bolero, Sumo, Scorpio, Safari and indeed the Indigo and the Logan too only have each other to beat. And it would seem that the two companies are rather happy in keeping it that way, case in point the new M&M SUV and Tata Aria/new Safari, both of which would again compete against each other. Both these companies have also understood that Indians tend to have American tastes in cars (tolerable quality, big size, cheap sticker price, and one can also add ugly looks to the list) and are happy as long as they are diesels...cause ofcourse, ours is a poor nation. Both these companies have miserably failed to show any automotive vision as well(unlike the japs or the koreans now) with their 'brand' associated with too many pies, and none of them bringing out a
Sagar
19th April,2010
Reply
Spot On.
Velutha
19th April,2010
Reply
For a so called 'experienced' motoring journalist you show a glaring lack of insight. Firstly judging by their latest effort, the Xylo, it is proof that Mahindra cannot make a decent car on their own. They are much better off with a partner. Why not court Peogeot/Citreon? They have a great range of small capacity petrol and diesel engines and good small car platforms. Most of its MUV/SUV are glorified 1960s jeeps. Technology has come a long way since then, you know. Even the current Logan is a much better car than what Mahindra can hope to develop in the next 5 years. So If they dont strike-up a JV modifying the Logan is the best shot they've got, else the Passenger vehicle department of Mahindra is heading for a rapid demise. A couple of cheap Japanese/Korean MUVs will blast them the History where they belong
Rohin Nagrani
19th April,2010
Reply
Dear Velutha, the attempt by Mahindra to get into JVs has been one of the reasons why they have been able to up their quality and engineering skills over the last 15 years. The Scorpio is one such example where their learnings from Ford (cue-curved glass, monocoque-type construction techniques) helped them. I've clearly pointed out that they will need some more external help, this could be another JV partner or experts from the field like Lotus, Cosworth or their kind. Apologies if that didn't come through in the blog. The Xylo still has scope for improvement, yes I agree with you on that. But it is the attitude of Mahindra towards accepting their problems and making improvements is what makes them stand out.
Velutha
19th April,2010
Reply
Woah! I wasn't really expecting such a prompt reply :) But really, curved glass, internal door hinges & coil springs is all they could learn in 15 years? I mean right now its the Bolero (essentially a 1960's jeep) that is really doing business for Mahindra. They did get lucky with the mHawk engine for the Scorpio, but that is it. They spent 4 years and a couple of hundred crores on the Xylo and don't have much to show for it. If they don't get their act together a.s.a.p their days are numbered. How long do they think they can continue to shove Vintage jeeps down unsuspecting customer's throats?
Twitter
Follow BSMotoring on Twitter
Most Popular
Read Emailed Commented
Other Manufacturers Other Models
Explore BSMOTORING.COM
  Home   Cars   Bikes   Gallery   General   Resources   Explore Group Network
 Quick Comparisons
 Road Tests
 Motofocus
 Motorsports
 Destinations
 Tests
 Reviews
 News
 Features
 Motorsports
 Motor shows
 Classics
 Quick Comparisons
 Tests
 Reviews
 News
 Features
 Motorsports
 Motor shows
 Classics
 Quick Comparisons
 Photo Gallery
 Video Gallery
 Wallpaper
 Travel
 Blogs
 Magazine
 About us
 Archives
 Register
 Feedback
 Archives
 Subscribe to Magazine
 Advertise with us
 Contact Us
 Business-standard.com
 bshindi.com
 Archives
 Livemarkets
 smartportfolio II